It’s a pretty easy link to make, since the hate mongers I speak of are those within scouting that actively promote discrimination by the Boy Scouts. I’ve seen a number of links this week about either gays or atheists not admitted into boy scouts. The city of Philadelphia recently decided to charge the Boy Scouts full rent on their meeting space, since the discount amounted to state sponsorship of an organization that discriminates. Steven Spielberg even stepped down from an advisory board position back in 2001.
“The last few years in scouting have deeply saddened me to see the Boy Scouts of America actively and publicly participating in discrimination. It’s a real shame,” Spielberg said from a prepared statement.
“I thought the Boy Scouts stood for equal opportunity and I have consistently spoken out publicly and privately against intolerance and discrimination based on ethnic, religious, racial and sexual orientation.”
The problem I see is that the Boy Scouts have taken so much charity from religious or quasi religious organizations that they are almost inseparable. I say this as a former scout who has camped at Brownsea, attended a national jamboree, earned every rank from Bobcat through Eagle, and is a member of the OA. My first cub scout pack met at school, as did my second and my first troop. My next two troops met at a Knights of Columbus hall and an American Legion post respectively. I did not have any trouble with any of my packs or troops, but I also wasn’t out, nor sure of my self, about my atheism at that point. I don’t think the court case on scout discrimination had been decided by the time I was finished with scouts, so it was also likely not a hot button issue yet. I can’t comment to much on the KoC troop as I only stayed with that troop for a few months. However, I think many atheist are aware of the damage to the separation of church and state caused by the KoC.
The American Legion hosted my last troop, and also sent me to Boys State in Virginia. The American Legion is a veterans group heavily focused towards “God and country.” Again, I never experienced any ill treatment from the Boy Scouts or the American Legion, I am trying to connect the dots. Boys State in Virginia was held at Liberty University. I had heard of Jerry Falwell, but I didn’t really know who he was or what he stood for. I didn’t know much about Liberty either. But these are the kind of people that the American Legion thinks are qualified to host young men, future leaders if you will, for a week of learning about government in action. There was prayer for the opening and closing of each day (they were mostly if not all Christian) as well as at plenty of other functions. Many of the “cities” as the groups they split the boys into are called, were very militaristic in nature, marching everywhere, doing push ups and sit ups before bed etc etc. My city was not like that at all. We were clearly the most civilian of the groups, walking and chatting, playing guitar at night instead of working out (and hanging out with a guy who is now in the NFL, our city was fun). I did “meet” Falwell while I was there, I was walking through the halls and he stopped me, asked me how I was enjoying myself and shook my hand. I am sure the Larry Flint remembrance of the man was quite accurate. While there I was also exposed for the first time to someone who thought that the music of Creed, yes “I am Jesus stapp” Creed, was evil. So this is the type of place and the type of people who can influence the Boy Scouts.
Why can these religious intolerants influence the Boy Scouts? Churches and religious organizations (and all organizations?) are always looking to expand their reach, and they usually have meeting space in their churches available for at least a few weeknights when Boy Scouts usually meet. Secular groups tend to not, since there are few atheist churches. So by allowing the scouts to use their facilities, they can exert influence. Now some people might argue that their local Boy Scout troop is supported by an episcopal church or a reform synagogue or by some other group that doesn’t discriminate. That is good, those are the kind of sponsors we need for the Boy Scouts. The scouts need those sponsors to speak up and counter the message from the ultra-conservative sponsors. We need sponsoring organizations, Eagle Scouts and OA members, scoutmaster, scouts and scout parents to all contact their local troop, council, region and the national board and tell them that you want scouts to end discrimination. We cannot loose scouting to bigots.
The Boy Scouts also discriminate against females, and I think they might have an easier time weeding them out than the gays and atheists. The British Scouts (the ones founded by BP) are equal access to everyone as far as I can tell. For some reason, discrimination against women comes up much less when talking about the Boy Scouts, and gets much less attention from everyone. Maybe because there are no internal dissidents, no former scouts who were secretly female the whole time they were scouts? I obviously failed to work it in above, but it is important. Sea scouts, for older scouts does not discriminate on gender, so there is a model internal to the Boy Scouts to reverse course on this.
Anyways, here’s some rescources:
BSA National Council - I didn’t find direct contact information, only a website feedback form. You could try asking for contact information.
Google Maps returned this information for the BSA National Offices:
1325 W Walnut Hill Ln, Irving, TX 75038
(972) 580-2000
Local Council Finder - Find your local council and talk to them. Try to find out if yours is one of the local councils that has tried to adopt non discrimination policies only to be rebuked by the national council. If they have tried, ask them how you can help them achieve your joint goal of equal access Boy Scouts.
BSAlegal - The BSA pro discrimination apologist website. Mostly seems to shout about first amendment right, which I agree, the scouts have. But just because you have a right doesn’t mean exercising it is the moral position, nor is it with out consequences. Discrimination may be their right, but it sure is ugly.